Your government kills people and tries to cover it up
Journalists shouldn’t trust official accounts when they know the officials are liars
News outlets have long conferred a high level of credibility to what government officials say. After all, they’re chosen through a democratic process, supposedly based on their competence and honesty.
In practice, of course, government officials sometimes lie and steal. And on a national level in the last decade, an entire political party has made it a matter of policy to lie brazenly to the public.
Now this party has made it a policy to cover up its own violence and even murder.
This is clear from what’s happened in Minneapolis in recent weeks, and what happened in the Chicago area before that and what happens in Homeland Security custody – 53 deaths since Donald Trump returned to power, including one this month ruled a homicide.
Early reports about Saturday’s fatal shooting of Alex Pretti in Minneapolis were understandably vague and cautious (“Federal agent shoots and kills man in Minneapolis, officials say”). But the true test of the news media was how they handled the story as it evolved.
Soon after the story broke and the first bystander video appeared, I offered advice for the media on Bluesky: “HOMELAND SECURITY LIES ROUTINELY AS A MATTER OF POLICY. If you feel compelled to include the Trump regime’s version of events, you must include that context.”
That advice was generally ignored, of course, but the release of another video and the account put forth by Homeland Security made it clear that the government was determined to lie about the incident – as it had with the killing of Renee Good three weeks ago.
The second video of the Pretti shooting clearly showed him holding a cellphone as he attempted to help a woman pepper-sprayed by Border Patrol agents. The agents wrestled Pretti to the ground, and though he had a legally owned firearm, the video appears to show an agent taking it from him before any gunfire occurred. Then agents fired a total of 10 shots at Pretti, including three to his back, killing him.
Homeland Security’s version of the incident was that Pretti “approached U.S. Border Patrol officers with a 9 mm semiautomatic handgun” and that he intended to “massacre law enforcement.” Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said Pretti was “brandishing” a weapon and accused him of “domestic terrorism.”
Some timid news outlets kept their headlines generic for hours. An exception was the New York Times – which I have frequently criticized in the past but will praise here. The NYT moved with good speed to headlines such as “Man Killed by Federal Agents Was Holding a Phone, Not a Gun” and “Videos Appear to Contradict Federal Accounts of Fatal Shooting.” It later dropped the hedging and said: “Videos Contradict Federal Accounts of Fatal Shooting.” (Here’s a gift link to an excellent NYT timeline.)
A day after the shooting, the NYT reported that the Trump regime was trying to ”justify an increasingly violent crackdown” by “immediately going on the offensive and demonizing the victim, often distorting the facts in the process.”
Homeland Security, as usual, is sticking to its lies. No investigation conducted by the regime will be credible. Already, the response of investigative agencies to Good’s murder has been so outrageous that federal officials have quit in protest.
The media’s overreliance on official accounts has long been a scandal. It has allowed law enforcement to get away with murder, literally. Journalists must stop relying on the accounts of officials they know are liars. Simple as that.
This puts the media in a tricky position: Do they believe eyewitnesses if they can find them? Do they believe advocacy groups? Attributing information to “officials” used to be a safe and easy position. Now journalists need to be more skeptical. Frankly, they should have been all along.
Video from smartphones and bodycams has made a huge difference in the public’s view of police-citizen encounters. But reliance on video has its hazards, too, in this age of AI fakery. News outlets must put adequate resources into verifying and analyzing such videos.
When I was an editor at the Chicago Tribune, we had a stark example of the dangers of trusting official accounts too much.
In 2014, a Black 17-year-old named Laquan McDonald was carrying a knife and walking away from police when he was gunned down – shot 16 times – by a white officer who had arrived on the scene only seconds earlier. The first account on the Tribune’s website relied on the account of a police union spokesman, an obviously biased source, that the shooting was justified. Officers on the scene gave false statements and police brass swept the case under the rug.
A week after Mayor Rahm Emanuel won re-election, the city disclosed a $5 million settlement with McDonald’s family, triggering new media interest. For months, the Emanuel administration resisted the release of dashcam video of the killing, until an independent journalist won a court order to pry it loose. The belated disclosure led to the second-degree murder conviction of the officer, who served three years in prison. It never would have happened without the video.
Journalists at the Tribune and other Chicago media realized we had messed up by trusting the official account. We learned a painful lesson. Everyone covering the actions of Homeland Security – the real domestic terrorists – must learn that lesson too.
This week’s media atrocity
Fox News wins the week’s dishonors with its parroting of the government’s false talking points about Minneapolis. The regime’s lies were so obvious that even Trump apologist Maria Bartiromo was asking hard questions on Fox, while her colleagues on the network kept performing as fascist puppets:
Fox co-host Charlie Hurt: “Only one person could have prevented this from happening and it’s Alex Pretti. He should have not been there.”
Fox host Lara Trump: “A Border Patrol agent, in fear for his life, shot an armed man.”
Fox host Griff Jenkins: “Why an individual would confront federal immigration law enforcement with a handgun is beyond me.”
Advertise in this newsletter
Do you or your company want to support COURIER’s mission and showcase your products or services to an aligned audience of 190,000+ subscribers at the same time? Contact advertising@couriernewsroom.com for more information.
ICYMI: Gloves Off is officially live
COURIER founder and publisher Tara McGowan kicked off her new show with Rep. Jasmine Crockett in a candid, yet hopeful conversation about power, courage, and what real leadership actually looks like. Stream the first episode now on YouTube, Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
Support COURIER’s Journalism
Democracy dies behind a paywall, so our journalism is and will always be free to our readers.
But to be able to make that commitment, we need support from folks like you who believe in our mission and support our unique model.
Journalists should stop reporting on KKK-Karoline’s press conferences. Stop giving their lies oxygen. Or… if you attend, fight back and stick up/call out her BS when he does a disingenuous and contemptuous take down of the journalist before you. Sitting there mute is not helpful. Or supportive of your journalist peers. Time to find your voices and fight back by calling out their bullshit in real time.
Now reports today that Trump is sending Tom Homan, border czar, to the Twin Cities to coordinate the investigation. Seems to me that's like throwing gas on a burning fire.